Smithey Ironware
Smithey Ironware Carbon Steel Oval Roaster
Best lightweight roaster for home cooks seeking cast iron performance.
Discover the exceptional performance of cast iron with the lightweight versatility of carbon steel in this Smithey Ironware Oval Roaster. Hand-forged by artisan Robert Thomas, each roaster is a unique piece, featuring hand-hammered handles for a secure grip and a beautifully pre-seasoned interior. Its oval shape and generous depth make it ideal for roasting meats, poultry, and vegetables, delivering outstanding results for all your culinary creations. Crafted in Charleston, SC, this roaster is built to be a cherished workhorse in your kitchen for years to come.
$295.00
Owner Satisfaction
4.8
/ 5
Category Rank
5
/ 517
#5 in Roasting Pans
Price vs Category Average
+150%
Above average
Material
Carbon Steel
/ Carbon Steel
Who it's for
- Home cooks seeking heirloom-quality tools that last a lifetime
- Culinary enthusiasts who prefer natural, chemical-free non-stick surfaces
- Hosts who frequently roast whole birds or large meat cuts
Who should skip it
- Budget-conscious shoppers looking for affordable kitchen essentials
- Busy cooks who prefer low-maintenance, dishwasher-safe cookware
- Users with limited wrist strength or difficulty lifting heavy items
Performance breakdown
Heat Retention
Carbon steel offers impressive thermal mass for consistent, even roasting results.
Weight Management
Significantly more maneuverable than traditional cast iron without sacrificing durability.
Surface Seasoning
Factory pre-seasoning provides a reliable non-stick foundation right out of the box.
Ergonomic Handling
Hand-hammered handles provide a secure, confident grip when moving heavy roasts.
Versatility
Transitions seamlessly from stovetop searing to oven roasting and table service.
Build Integrity
Artisan-forged construction ensures a lifetime of heavy-duty kitchen performance.
Key Specs
Material
Carbon Steel
Shape
Oval
Length
13.5 inches
Width (top)
9.5 inches
Depth
+/-1.75 inches
Total length
16.5 inches
Weight
+/-4.5 lbs
Handle Type
Hand-hammered
Features
- Hand-forged, unique carbon steel construction
- Lighter weight than cast iron
- Easy-grip, hand-hammered handles
- Pre-seasoned for immediate use
- Rivals cast iron performance
- Versatile for roasting and baking
- Made in Charleston, SC
What customers say
Customers view the Smithey Carbon Steel Oval Roaster as a worthwhile investment, praising its heirloom quality and beautiful polished finish. The core theme is exceptional craftsmanship and superior cooking performance. Reviewers consistently highlight the carbon steel's superb heat control, making it versatile for roasting and searing. While the initial cost is high, most buyers agree the longevity and quality justify the price. Users feel deep satisfaction and pride of ownership in this durable, high performing piece of equipment designed to last generations. Minor upkeep is noted but overshadowed by the overall positive experience.
Know before you buy
Carbon steel offers the same heat retention and searing capabilities as cast iron but at a significantly lighter weight. This makes the roaster easier to maneuver in and out of the oven while still providing the consistent, even heat required for perfect roasting.
Yes, each roaster comes pre-seasoned from the Smithey workshop. You can begin cooking with it immediately, though the seasoning will continue to improve and become more non-stick with regular use.
Hand wash the roaster with warm water and a mild soap if necessary, then dry it thoroughly immediately after cleaning. To maintain the seasoning, apply a very light coat of oil to the surface before storing it in a dry place.
Yes, because the handles are made of carbon steel, they will become hot along with the rest of the pan. Always use oven mitts or heavy-duty pot holders when removing the roaster from the oven.
Absolutely. Carbon steel is highly versatile and can be used on gas, electric, and induction stovetops to sear meats before transferring the entire pan into the oven to finish the roasting process.
Still have a question?
Ask Hayley anything about this product before you decide.
Ready to buy?
$295