Fiesta
XL Butter Dish Top
Best replacement top for owners of existing oversized ceramic butter dishes.
Add a touch of charm to your table with this replacement butter dish top in a delightful Meadow hue. Crafted from durable ceramic, it's designed to perfectly fit the corresponding butter dish bottom. Please note that as these are often hand-picked seconds, minor imperfections like pin pops or glaze skips may be present, ensuring each piece has unique character. This essential serving component offers a stylish way to complete your butter dish.
$14.99
Owner Satisfaction
4.5
/ 5
Category Rank
352
/ 765
#352 in Butter Dishes
Price vs Category Average
-78%
Below average
Material
Ceramic
/ Ceramic
Who it's for
- Fiesta collectors valuing long-term durability and vibrant aesthetics
- Busy households needing dishwasher-safe convenience and easy handling
- Gourmet cooks using European-style or bulk butter sticks
Who should skip it
- Budget-conscious shoppers seeking affordable replacements or exact color matches
- Minimalists with limited kitchen counter or refrigerator storage
- Clumsy users preferring shatterproof plastic or metal alternatives
Performance breakdown
Ceramic Durability
Dense, high-fired ceramic construction stands up well to daily kitchen use.
Aesthetic Appeal
The signature Meadow glaze brings a vibrant, classic charm to tabletops.
Finish Consistency
Expect minor glaze skips and pin pops due to factory-second sourcing.
Ergonomic Design
The handle lid provides a secure, comfortable grip for easy access.
System Compatibility
Engineered specifically to pair perfectly with the XL butter dish base.
Replacement Utility
A practical solution for restoring a complete set without buying new.
Key Specs
Material
Ceramic
Lid Type
Handle Lid
Shape
Novelty
Pattern Theme
Solid
Product Type
Replacement Top for XL Butter Dish
Color
Meadow
Compatibility
XL Butter Dish Bottom
Condition Note
Hand-picked seconds may have minor glaze imperfections
Know before you buy
No, this lid is specifically designed to fit the XL Butter Dish bottom. It will not fit the standard-sized Fiesta butter dish.
Fiesta seconds are authentic pieces that may have minor cosmetic imperfections, such as small glaze skips or pin pops. These do not affect the functionality of the lid and give each piece a unique character.
Yes, this lid features the standard Fiesta Meadow glaze. While minor variations can occur in ceramic production, it is designed to match the rest of the Meadow collection.
No, this product is a replacement top only. It is intended for customers who already own the XL Butter Dish bottom and need to replace a lost or broken lid.
Yes, like most Fiesta ceramic products, this lid is dishwasher safe. However, due to the nature of the glaze, hand washing can help maintain the finish over time.
Still have a question?
Ask Hayley anything about this product before you decide.
Ready to buy?
$15