Smithey Ironware
Smithey Carbon Steel Paella Pan
Best large-format pan for hosts who love cooking and serving outdoors.
Elevate your culinary gatherings with the Smithey Carbon Steel Paella Pan, expertly hand-forged in Charleston, SC. This pan offers the largest cooking surface in Smithey's collection, ideal for crafting authentic paella or serving appetizers. Its smooth interior and substantial helper handles ensure comfortable handling, while the pre-seasoned carbon steel is ready for immediate use. Versatile for open flames, ovens, and various stovetops, it's designed to be a stunning centerpiece for any festive occasion, blending exceptional performance with striking presentation.
$199.95
Owner Satisfaction
4.8
/ 5
Category Rank
1
/ 159
Best Paella Pans
Price vs Category Average
+56%
Above average
Diameter (top)
17
/ inches
Who it's for
- Collectors seeking durable, heirloom-quality kitchenware
- Versatile chefs needing one pan for searing and roasting
- Home cooks aiming for a perfect, crispy socarrat
Who should skip it
- Busy cooks preferring low-maintenance, dishwasher-safe cookware
- Users with limited wrist strength or mobility
- Budget-conscious shoppers looking for entry-level pans
Performance breakdown
Heat Distribution
Carbon steel construction ensures rapid, even searing across the entire surface.
Surface Capacity
The expansive diameter easily accommodates large-format meals for festive gatherings.
Build Durability
Hand-forged craftsmanship creates a lifetime tool that withstands intense heat.
Handling Ergonomics
Oversized helper handles provide necessary stability for moving heavy, loaded pans.
Seasoning Readiness
Pre-seasoned finish allows for immediate cooking without extensive initial preparation.
Aesthetic Appeal
Striking design transitions seamlessly from the stovetop to the dining table.
Key Specs
Diameter (top)
17 inches
Total diameter (handle to handle)
20.5 inches
Cook Surface
13.4 inches
Capacity
7 QT
Weight
9.0 lbs
Depth
2 inches
Material
Carbon Steel
Hand-forged in Charleston, SC
Features
- Largest cooking surface for entertaining
- Hand-forged for superior craftsmanship
- Smooth interior finish for easier use
- Visually stunning design
- Versatile for multiple heat sources
- Designed for cooking and presentation
- Oversized helper handles for secure grip
- Pre-seasoned and ready for immediate use
What customers say
Reviewers consistently praise the Smithey Paella Pan for its exceptional quality and beautiful craftsmanship. The polished carbon steel surface delivers superior nonstick performance after seasoning, simplifying cleanup significantly compared to other carbon steel options. Although this pan is a notable investment, customers feel the heirloom quality and stunning design fully justify the premium cost. Its excellent heat distribution is frequently highlighted as key to achieving perfect paella results.
Know before you buy
Yes, the carbon steel construction is compatible with induction, as well as gas, electric, and open flame heat sources.
No, the pan comes pre-seasoned from the factory and is ready to use immediately. You can continue to build the seasoning over time with regular cooking and proper maintenance.
The pan weighs 9 pounds. While substantial, the oversized helper handles are designed to provide a secure and balanced grip, even when moving the pan from the oven to the table.
Absolutely. Its large surface area and 2-inch depth make it excellent for searing meats, roasting vegetables, or serving large-format appetizers directly at the table.
Hand wash the pan with warm water and a mild soap if necessary, then dry it thoroughly immediately after cleaning. Applying a very light coat of oil before storing will help prevent rust and maintain the seasoning.
With a total diameter of 20.5 inches including the handles, you should measure your oven interior before purchasing. It fits most standard 30-inch wide ovens, but it is a tight fit for smaller units.
Still have a question?
Ask Hayley anything about this product before you decide.
Ready to buy?
$200