Amish Quiet Night Plush Single-Sided Mattress
Best plush mattress for sleepers seeking durable, handcrafted spinal support.
Experience superior craftsmanship with the Amish Quiet Night Pillowtop Single-Sided Mattress, designed for consistent support and comfort. Its single-sided innerspring system promotes proper spinal alignment and minimizes motion transfer for undisturbed sleep. The plush pillowtop layer adds cushioning without compromising structural integrity. Meticulously handcrafted from quality materials, this mattress offers a balanced feel, making it a reliable choice for restful, long-term sleep. Available in various sizes, it's built for durability and everyday performance.
$173.00
Owner Satisfaction
4.6
/ 5
Category Rank
265
/ 6141
#265 in Mattresses
Price vs Category Average
-90%
Below average
Dimensions
387510388010537510538010608010768010728410
/ TWIN: " W X " L X " H; TWIN XL: " W X " L X " H; FULL: " W X " L X " H; FULL XL: " W X " L X " H; QUEEN: " W X " L X " H; KING: " W X " L X " H; CALIFORNIA KING: " W X " L X " H
Who it's for
- Couples seeking undisturbed sleep despite a restless partner
- Shoppers valuing heirloom-quality construction and long-term durability
- Side sleepers requiring extra cushioning for sensitive joints
Who should skip it
- Owners wanting to extend mattress life through regular flipping
- Individuals who frequently sit on the edge of the bed
- Stomach sleepers or those needing firm spinal alignment
Performance breakdown
Build Integrity
Handcrafted construction ensures superior structural longevity compared to mass-produced alternatives.
Motion Isolation
Innerspring design effectively dampens movement for a more undisturbed sleep experience.
Surface Comfort
Plush pillowtop layer provides a soft, inviting feel without sacrificing necessary support.
Spinal Alignment
Engineered for consistent support that promotes healthy posture throughout the night.
Material Quality
Premium North American components reflect a commitment to traditional, durable craftsmanship.
Warranty Coverage
The one-year protection period is somewhat limited for a long-term investment.
Key Specs
Dimensions
TWIN: 38" W X 75" L X 10" H; TWIN XL: 38" W X 80" L X 10" H; FULL: 53" W X 75" L X 10" H; FULL XL: 53" W X 80" L X 10" H; QUEEN: 60" W X 80" L X 10" H; KING: 76" W X 80" L X 10" H; CALIFORNIA KING: 72" W X 84" L X 10" H
Materials
Solid North American Hardwood
Made In
United States
Warranty
ONE YEAR warranty against any craftsmanship defects or workmanship.
Features
- Handcrafted by Amish craftsmen
- Single-sided innerspring system
- Pillowtop comfort layer
- Durable construction
- Built for comfort, strength, and long-lasting everyday performance
What customers say
Customers consistently praise the Amish Quiet Night Plush mattress for its exceptional comfort and traditional craftsmanship. Many reviewers highlight the plush surface as providing a cloud like feel that supports restful sleep without sagging over time. The single sided design is noted for its simplicity and durability. Owners feel the mattress offers significant value because it combines high quality materials with a reasonable price point. This mattress is frequently described as a reliable choice for those seeking a balance of softness and structural integrity from a trusted brand.
Know before you buy
No, this is a single-sided mattress. It is designed to be used on one side only, so you do not need to flip it, though rotating it occasionally can help maintain even wear.
The pillowtop layer provides an extra cushion of comfort on the surface, softening the initial feel while the underlying innerspring system maintains the structural support needed for proper spinal alignment.
Because this mattress is built with a durable innerspring system, it performs best on a solid, supportive foundation or a box spring that provides even surface coverage to prevent sagging.
Yes, the innerspring system is specifically engineered to minimize motion transfer. This helps ensure that movement on one side of the bed is less likely to disturb a partner on the other side.
The one-year warranty covers defects related to craftsmanship and workmanship. It ensures that the mattress is free from manufacturing errors that could affect its structural integrity or performance.
Still have a question?
Ask Hayley anything about this product before you decide.