Amish Elite Plush Two-Sided Mattress
Best durable mattress for sleepers seeking long-lasting, reversible comfort.
The Amish Elite Premier Plush Two-Sided Mattress is a testament to superior craftsmanship and enduring quality. Handcrafted by Amish artisans, this mattress features a robust innerspring system designed for both firm support and plush comfort. Its reversible design ensures longevity and consistent performance, making it ideal for diverse sleep needs. Built with a solid hardwood frame, it promises durability and reliable, long-lasting everyday performance. This mattress combines traditional Amish quality with advanced innerspring technology for enhanced sleep quality and a comfortable night's rest.
$490.00
Owner Satisfaction
4.6
/ 5
Category Rank
265
/ 6148
#265 in Mattresses
Price vs Category Average
-71%
Below average
Dimensions
387513388013537513538013608013768013728413
/ TWIN: " W X " L X " H, TWIN XL: " W X " L X " H, FULL: " W X " L X " H, FULL XL: " W X " L X " H, QUEEN: " W X " L X " H, KING: " W X " L X " H, CALIFORNIA KING: " W X " L X " H
Who it's for
- Side sleepers needing soft cushioning combined with essential spinal support
- Value-conscious shoppers seeking a mattress that lasts for years
- Quality-focused buyers who appreciate traditional, artisanal manufacturing standards
Who should skip it
- Budget-minded shoppers looking for a more affordable, entry-level mattress
- Solo sleepers who struggle to move or rotate heavy furniture
- Light sleepers easily disturbed by a partner's nighttime movements
Performance breakdown
Build Integrity
Solid hardwood foundation provides a robust, heirloom-quality structural base.
Longevity Potential
Reversible design effectively doubles the lifespan of the sleep surface.
Support Consistency
Innerspring architecture delivers reliable, firm alignment across the entire mattress.
Surface Comfort
Plush cushioning layers offer a soft, inviting feel without sacrificing support.
Craftsmanship Quality
Handcrafted construction highlights meticulous attention to detail and traditional assembly.
Warranty Coverage
One-year protection is notably short for a premium, handcrafted mattress investment.
Key Specs
Dimensions
TWIN: 38" W X 75" L X 13" H, TWIN XL: 38" W X 80" L X 13" H, FULL: 53" W X 75" L X 13" H, FULL XL: 53" W X 80" L X 13" H, QUEEN: 60" W X 80" L X 13" H, KING: 76" W X 80" L X 13" H, CALIFORNIA KING: 72" W X 84" L X 13" H
Materials
Solid North American Hardwood
Made In
United States
Warranty
ONE YEAR warranty against any craftsmanship defects or workmanship.
Features
- Handcrafted by Amish craftsmen, showcasing remarkable skill, precision, and enduring quality.
- Reversible design balances firm support with plush comfort.
- Solid hardwood construction ensures durability and longevity.
- Built for comfort, strength, and long-lasting everyday performance.
What customers say
Customers consistently praise the Amish Elite Plush Two Sided Mattress for its exceptional comfort and traditional craftsmanship. The flippable design is a standout feature that many users find adds significant longevity and value compared to modern one sided alternatives. Reviewers often highlight the plush surface which provides a cloud like feel while maintaining necessary support. This mattress earns high marks for its durable construction and the peace of mind that comes with hand crafted quality. It is a reliable choice for those seeking a classic sleep experience with modern comfort levels.
Know before you buy
The two-sided design allows you to flip and rotate the mattress regularly. This prevents uneven wear, helps the materials settle more consistently over time, and can significantly extend the overall lifespan of the mattress compared to one-sided models.
The solid North American hardwood frame provides a rigid, stable foundation that prevents sagging and edge collapse. It ensures the mattress maintains its structural integrity and support level, even after years of daily use.
The Amish Elite is designed to be a 'plush' mattress, meaning it offers a softer, more cushioned surface feel. However, because it utilizes a robust innerspring system, it still provides the underlying structural support necessary for proper spinal alignment.
Every size of the Amish Elite mattress features a uniform height of 13 inches. You should ensure your bed frame or foundation can accommodate this profile, especially if you are using a standard box spring.
To maintain the integrity of the innerspring and comfort layers, we recommend flipping and rotating the mattress every three to six months. This practice ensures even distribution of weight and prevents body impressions from forming in one specific area.
Still have a question?
Ask Hayley anything about this product before you decide.