Smithey Ironware
Smithey Cast Iron Flat Top Griddle
Best premium griddle for serious home cooks seeking heirloom quality.
This versatile piece of cookware serves a dual purpose in the kitchen, acting as both a flat-top griddle for searing, frying, and grilling, and a custom-fit lid for matching skillets. Designed with a nod to vintage aesthetics, it incorporates modern manufacturing techniques to ensure consistent heat distribution and durability. The surface is ideal for everything from delicate crepes and eggs to hearty grilled sandwiches. It even includes specialized covers for pour spouts, ensuring a tight seal when used as a lid. This artisanal tool is built to last for generations, becoming a staple in any home kitchen.
$124.95
More Flat Top Griddle Options
Owner Satisfaction
4.7
/ 5
Category Rank
6
/ 650
#6 in Griddles & Grill Pans
Price vs Category Average
+33%
Above average
Material
Cast Iron
/ Cast Iron
Who it's for
- Home cooks seeking a vintage-style surface with modern performance
- Entertainers who value kitchen tools that transition to elegant servingware
- Serious chefs requiring precise temperature control for delicate searing tasks
Who should skip it
- Individuals with limited wrist strength or those preferring lightweight cookware
- Budget-conscious shoppers looking for basic utility over artisanal craftsmanship
- Busy users who prefer the convenience of dishwasher-safe kitchen tools
Performance breakdown
Heat Retention
Heavy-gauge cast iron holds temperature steady for consistent, even searing.
Versatility
Seamlessly transitions from a stovetop griddle to a functional skillet lid.
Surface Finish
Polished interior provides a smooth, non-stick cooking surface right out of box.
Build Quality
Artisanal craftsmanship ensures this heirloom piece will last for generations.
Ease of Maintenance
Requires traditional cast iron seasoning rituals to maintain its performance.
Ergonomics
Thoughtful handle design makes maneuvering the heavy iron surprisingly manageable.
Key Specs
Material
Cast Iron
Pour Spout Covers
Included
Function
Griddle and Skillet Lid
Compatibility
Fits matching size skillets
Know before you buy
This griddle is specifically engineered to fit Smithey Ironware skillets of the corresponding size. While it may physically rest on other brands, the pour spout covers are custom-molded to the exact geometry of Smithey skillets, so you will not get a proper seal on other brands.
Because it is made of heavy-duty cast iron, it acts as a self-basting lid that retains heat exceptionally well. It adds significant weight to your skillet, which helps trap steam and moisture inside, making it ideal for braising or finishing dishes that require consistent, even heat.
Yes. Smithey finishes their cast iron to be exceptionally smooth right out of the box, unlike the rough, pebbly texture found on many mass-produced pans. It provides a near-nonstick surface that performs beautifully for delicate items once properly seasoned.
The pour spout covers are integrated into the design, so you clean them exactly as you would the rest of the griddle. Just ensure you dry them thoroughly after washing to prevent any moisture from getting trapped in the crevices, which could lead to surface rust.
It is significantly heavier than standard lids. Because it is solid cast iron, it provides substantial thermal mass, but you should be prepared for the extra weight when lifting it to check on your food.
Still have a question?
Ask Hayley anything about this product before you decide.
Ready to buy?
$125